ITC Final Determination: Ninestar Does Not Infringe!
On May 20, 2019, the United States International Trade Commission (“ITC”) issued a notice to affirm the Administrative Law Judge (“ALJ”)’s initial determination (“ID”) (Order No. 40) granting Ninestar, Static and some other respondents’ respective motions for summary determination of non-infringement. Accordingly, the Commission has determined to find no violation of section 337 and the investigation is terminated.
By way of background, Canon Inc., Canon U.S.A., and Canon Virginia, Inc. (collectively, “Canon”) initiated this ITC investigation by filing a complaint on February 28, 2018, alleging that certain toner cartridges and components made and/sold by Ninestar, Static, Print-Rite, Aster and numerous other respondents infringe 9 of Canon’s U.S. patents. On June 13, 2018, Canon filed a motion to amend the complaint which reduced the number of patents to 7: U.S. Patent Nos. 9,746,826; 9,836,021; 9,841,729; 9,857,764; 9,857,765; 9,869,960; 9,874,846.
Previously, Canon filed numerous patent infringement lawsuits against aftermarket companies in federal district courts and before the ITC. Canon’s previous enforcement efforts have largely been successful, securing settlements, injunctions, exclusion orders, and default judgments.
As always, Ninestar mounted a fierce defense. The ITC record shows that on August 30, 2018, the ALJ held a Markman hearing (i.e., a hearing to determine the scope of Canon’s asserted patents). The hearing transcript obtained from the ITC’s online docket shows that two attorneys representing Ninestar and Static argued the case for all respondents only.
On February 28, 2019, the ALJ issued the Markman order agreeing with Ninestar and Static on critical claim construction inssues. In light of the Markman order, Canon stipulated to non-infringement of the accused products by Ninestar, Static and others. As a result, the ALJ issued the ID of non-infringement on March 13, 2019. “We are very pleased that the ITC confirmed that Ninestar does not infringe Canon’s patents,” said Jason Wang, General Manager of Ninestar Image Tech Limited. “Ninestar takes great pride in developing innovative cutting-edge products, protected by Ninestar’s own intellectual ;property,” Jason added.